Can a person be charged with a crime without evidence?

Home > FAQs > Can a person be charged with a crime without evidence?

No, a person cannot be charged with a crime without evidence. There must be sufficient evidence to establish probable cause that the person committed the crime. This requirement ensures fairness in the legal process and prevents baseless accusations.

At The Johnson Firm, our Lake Charles criminal defense attorneys are committed to providing clarity and support, understanding the importance of evidence in upholding justice.

can a person be charged with a crime without evidence

What counts as evidence?

Evidence can come in many forms, including but not limited to:

Physical evidence: Something tangible related to the crime, like a weapon or stolen items.
Witness testimony: Statements from people who saw the crime happen or have relevant information.
Video or photographic evidence: Recordings that capture the crime or events related to it.
Forensic evidence: Scientific data like DNA, fingerprints, or blood analysis.

Even circumstantial evidence, which suggests a crime has been committed without directly proving it, can be used to charge someone. However, the evidence must logically lead to the conclusion that the suspect likely committed the crime.

Legal standards for charging someone with a crime in Louisiana

In Louisiana, as in all states, the standard for charging someone with a crime is that there must be “probable cause.” This means that the evidence must be strong enough to convince a reasonable person that the suspect committed the crime. Louisiana’s Code of Criminal Procedure discusses how an arrest warrant is issued based on adequate evidence presented to a judge that supports the likelihood of an offense being committed by the suspect.

Related article:

How do I find out if there’s a warrant for my arrest in Louisiana?

Can mistakes happen?

Yes, unfortunately, mistakes can happen. Sometimes, charges are brought based on misunderstandings or incomplete evidence. In other cases, individuals might be wrongly accused due to misidentification, misleading circumstantial evidence, or even malicious accusations.

What should I do If I’ve been charged without sufficient evidence?

Remain calm: It’s crucial not to let emotions get the better of you. Remaining calm will help you handle the situation more effectively.
Exercise your rights: You have the right to remain silent and the right to an attorney. Use these rights wisely to protect yourself.
Contact an attorney: Engaging a knowledgeable criminal defense lawyer is crucial. An attorney can evaluate the evidence, argue for your rights, and work to have unjust charges dismissed.

Charged with a crime? The Johnson Firm is ready to help.

At The Johnson Firm, we specialize in criminal defense and understand how daunting and confusing the charge process can be, especially if you believe the evidence against you is flawed or non-existent.

Contact us online or call (337) 433-1414 today. We are here to ensure that justice is served fairly and that your legal journey is as smooth and understandable as possible.